The water pumps from TFS come with a gasket, but even they recommend using a different (better) gasket.
Get the gasket for your thermostat housing, if you remove that.
I suspect your problem, though, is a leaky cap. Simple to replace, if so. You can wrap some paper towels over the cap, and down the housing, hold in place with a rubber band, and go for a drive. If the paper towels end up wet, you have your answer.